Hawaii
with kids
Two trips, four islands, and which one we’d pick for your family. Big Island and Maui in March 2024, Oahu and Kauai in November 2025.
- Trips
- 2 trips, 4 islands
- Nights
- 21
- Kids’ ages
- 7 & 2, then 9 & 4
- We paid
- $8,947
- Cash price
- $31,053
Quick verdict
The only place we’ve been back to, and we’d go again.
- Best island for young kids
- Maui. The best mix of nature, beaches and downtime.
- Our favorite
- Big Island and Kauai, for pure nature.
- Need a car?
- Yes. We rented one on every island.
- How long?
- At least a week. The flights from the mainland are long.
Which Hawaiian island is best for families?
We’ve now done all four big islands with the boys, and each one has a completely different personality. Here’s our honest ranking. As parents we’re a little biased toward Big Island, because we love nature. But if you’re taking young kids and can only pick one, we’d send you to Maui: it has the best balance of nature, beaches and plain relaxing.
Big Island
The most variety. Lava, volcanoes, great snorkeling, and a sunset above the clouds on Mauna Kea. It felt like four trips in one.
Pick it if: your family loves nature and adventure.
No.2
Kauai
The most dramatic scenery in Hawaii. The Na Pali Coast and Waimea Canyon, plus the boys’ favorite day of either trip: a shelter-dog field trip.
Pick it if: you want slow, green and scenic.
No.3
Maui
The best all-rounder for kids. The Road to Hana, Haleakalā, and a Trilogy snorkel trip to Lanai.
Pick it if: it’s your first Hawaii trip with young kids.
No.4
Oahu
Honestly, a bit overrated for us. Tons to do and Waikiki Beach is amazing, but it’s busy. At times it felt more like a big city than an island.
Pick it if: you want lots of activities and history, like Pearl Harbor.
One thing we’d add: the hotel matters more than you’d think. After a big day out, a great pool or beach right outside made a real difference for the boys, and for us.
Our two Hawaii trips
Both times we did two islands in one trip. Points covered the big stuff, flights and hotels, so most of what we paid was food, cars and activities. Each island guide has the full day-by-day and every line of the costs.
Big Island, then Maui
- Flights: 160K Amex points, moved to British Airways Avios and booked on American
- Marriott Waikoloa, 2 nights: 2 Marriott free night certificates
- Holiday Inn Big Island, 4 nights: 120K IHG points
- Hyatt Regency Maui, 5 nights: 175K Hyatt points, resort fee waived
- Maui Ocean Center: free with our ASTC science-museum membership
- We paid
- $5,221
- Cash price
- $15,981
Oahu, then Kauai
- Flights: 104K Finnair Avios, booked on American
- Holiday Inn Oahu, 4 nights: 118K IHG points
- Grand Hyatt Kauai, 6 nights: 150K Hyatt points
- Checked bags: free with our American Gold status
- Na Pali boat tour: $160 off with Amex Offers and Viator codes
- We paid
- $3,726
- Cash price
- $15,072
How we flew to Hawaii on points
Flights to Hawaii are the most expensive part when you’re coming from the Midwest or the East Coast, so that’s where points help most.
Trip 1: we transferred Amex points to British Airways Avios and used them to book American Airlines flights for the four of us.
Trip 2 was a smarter redemption. We used Finnair Avios to book the same kind of American flights. From the Midwest or East Coast, Finnair Avios are our best bet for Hawaii: great value, and we found award seats easily. It worked so well that I helped two other families book their flights the same way. Four families went on that trip in the end, and three of us flew on points.
Flights between the islands are short and cheap, so we just paid cash for those.
How we book flights with pointsIncluding Avios on American
Read the flight guideWhat we’d tell you before you go
- 1Do two islands if you can.Inter-island flights are short and cheap, and every island feels different. Two islands in one trip worked great for us both times.
- 2Stay at least a week.The flight from the mainland is long. Give yourselves time to enjoy it, not just recover from it.
- 3Look at Finnair Avios for your flights.Our best-value way to fly a family of four to Hawaii on American.
- 4Hit Costco on day one.Every island we visited has one. Stock up on snacks, drinks and sunscreen before you get to resort prices.
- 5Book boat and snorkel tours early.Trilogy on Maui, snorkel trips on Big Island and Na Pali boat tours on Kauai fill up. Book once your dates are set.
- 6Check your memberships.Our ASTC science-museum membership got us into the Maui Ocean Center for free.
- 7Hawaii is great for points hotels.We’ve used Hyatt, IHG and Marriott across the islands, and all of them were good value.
Grand Cayman
Caribbean cruise
The cards behind both trips